What is Plymouth Rock?
Plymouth Rock is one of the most famous historical landmarks in the United States, widely believed to be the disembarkation site of the Mayflower Pilgrims who founded Plymouth Colony in December 1620. However, despite its iconic status, the rock’s historical authenticity as the Pilgrims’ actual landing site remains a subject of debate. While no contemporary accounts from the Pilgrims mention it, the rock has become a lasting symbol of American heritage. Over the centuries, it has been moved, altered, and commemorated, yet its significance endures in American culture.
Plymouth Rock bears the inscription “1620,” marking the year the Pilgrims arrived on the Mayflower.
The Historical Context of the Mayflower Pilgrims
The Mayflower Pilgrims, a group of English separatists seeking religious freedom, set sail from England in September 1620. After a difficult voyage, they first landed in what is now Provincetown, Massachusetts, in November 1620. The Pilgrims spent several weeks exploring the Cape Cod region before ultimately selecting Plymouth as the site for their colony. On December 21, 1620, they began disembarking and establishing what would become one of the earliest English settlements in North America.
Despite its prominent place in popular history, Plymouth Rock was not mentioned in any of the Pilgrims’ original writings. Edward Winslow’s Mourt’s Relation (1622) and William Bradford’s Of Plymouth Plantation (written between 1630 and 1651) provide detailed accounts of the Pilgrims’ landing and early struggles but do not reference the rock. This lack of primary source documentation raises questions about the rock’s historical accuracy as the actual landing site.
The Emergence of Plymouth Rock as a Historical Landmark
The first recorded reference to Plymouth Rock dates back to 1715, nearly a century after the Pilgrims’ arrival. Town boundary records described it as “a great rock.” However, it was not until 1741 that Plymouth Rock was officially associated with the Pilgrims’ landing. A 94-year-old church elder named Thomas Faunce claimed that his father and other early settlers had identified the rock as the exact location where the Pilgrims stepped ashore. Faunce, whose father had arrived in Plymouth in 1623, provided a link to the first generation of settlers. His testimony was accepted by the townspeople, solidifying the rock’s status as a sacred relic of American history.
Plymouth Rock is a historical site traditionally associated with the Mayflower Pilgrims’ landing in 1620.
According to historical accounts, Faunce was brought to the rock in a chair to bid it farewell before a planned construction project would cover it. With tears in his eyes, he declared it the true landing site of the Pilgrims. His claim deeply influenced public perception, and the rock was preserved rather than buried. Although there is no concrete evidence to support Faunce’s assertion, his story became a cornerstone of Plymouth’s historical identity.
The Rock’s Movements and Fragmentation
Plymouth Rock’s journey has been anything but stationary. In 1774, as the American Revolution was beginning, the townspeople decided to move the rock to Plymouth’s Town Square to serve as a patriotic symbol. However, during the attempt to relocate it, the rock split in two. The bottom portion remained at the wharf, while the top half was placed in Town Square. Over the years, pieces of the rock were chipped away and taken as souvenirs or displayed in other locations.
In 1834, the top portion of Plymouth Rock was moved to Pilgrim Hall Museum. The remaining section at the waterfront was encased in a Victorian-style canopy in 1867. In 1880, the two halves were reunited at the original wharf location, and the date “1620” was inscribed into the rock. This reunification further cemented its role as a historical artifact, despite the changes it had undergone.
Over the centuries, Plymouth Rock has been moved, altered, and debated, yet it continues to hold a special place in American history.
The rock was moved again in 1920 during a waterfront restoration project. Architect Arthur Shurcliff designed a new setting for the rock, ensuring that it would be at sea level to mimic its original placement. Today, it rests beneath a classical granite portico designed by McKim, Mead & White, where it is protected by a metal grate and viewed by thousands of visitors each year.
Debates Over the Rock’s Authenticity
Although Plymouth Rock remains a cherished national symbol, modern historians question its actual role in the Pilgrims’ landing. Critics argue that it is unlikely the Pilgrims would have chosen a large, exposed boulder as a landing point when more practical locations were available. Additionally, the Pilgrims had landed in multiple locations, including Provincetown, before arriving in Plymouth, further diminishing the likelihood that a single rock held special significance.
Although there is no definitive proof that the Pilgrims landed on this specific rock, its legacy as a representation of their journey and struggles remains unchallenged.
Notable critics include journalist Bill Bryson, who stated that “the one thing the Pilgrims certainly did not do was step ashore on Plymouth Rock.” He and other skeptics believe that the story originated from later generations rather than firsthand accounts. Additionally, the construction of a wharf over the rock and its numerous relocations over the centuries make it difficult to verify its original position.
Nevertheless, Plymouth Rock’s symbolic power remains undiminished. It represents the Pilgrims’ perseverance, the founding of New England, and the broader ideals of American history. The story of the rock, whether entirely factual or partly legendary, continues to resonate with visitors.
The Rock’s Role in American Culture and Heritage
Plymouth Rock has become more than just a physical landmark—it is a cultural icon. Over the years, pieces of the rock have been displayed in various locations, including the Smithsonian Institution and Pilgrim Hall Museum. A 40-pound fragment is also housed at Plymouth Church in Brooklyn, New York, where abolitionist Henry Ward Beecher once preached.
In the 19th century, French historian Alexis de Tocqueville remarked on the rock’s symbolic importance, noting that its fragments were treasured across the United States. He observed that even a simple stone could become an object of veneration when linked to a powerful historical narrative.
The rock’s significance was further solidified by its inclusion in public ceremonies and commemorations. In 1921, President Warren G. Harding visited Plymouth Rock during the tercentenary celebration of the Pilgrims’ landing. Over the years, it has been the focal point of various patriotic events, reinforcing its status as a foundational symbol of the United States.
The monumental canopy built in 1867 sheltered Plymouth Rock until 1920.
Modern Preservation Efforts
Today, Plymouth Rock is part of Pilgrim Memorial State Park and managed by the Massachusetts Department of Conservation and Recreation. The site attracts over a million visitors annually, making it one of the most visited historical landmarks in the country. Interpretive guides provide historical context, explaining both the facts and the myths surrounding the rock.
Whether viewed as a literal landing site or a symbolic cornerstone of the nation’s origins, Plymouth Rock remains an essential part of the American story.
Despite its popularity, Plymouth Rock has suffered from natural erosion and human interference. In addition to the damage from its multiple relocations, tourists have chipped away small pieces over the years. Preservation efforts have focused on protecting the rock from further degradation while ensuring that it remains accessible to the public. The canopy built over the rock helps shield it from the elements, while park staff monitor its condition.
St. Augustine: The First Permanent European Settlement in America
Frequently Asked Questions about Plymouth Rock
Did the Pilgrims mention Plymouth Rock in their writings?
No, there is no record of the Pilgrims referring to Plymouth Rock in their documents.
Who first claimed Plymouth Rock as the Pilgrims’ landing site?
Thomas Faunce, a 94-year-old church elder, in 1741—121 years after the landing.
An illustration entitled “The Landing of the Pilgrims”. It was created by US painter Henry A. Bacon.
Has Plymouth Rock always been in its original location?
No, it has been moved multiple times, including its relocation in 1920.
Why was Plymouth Rock moved in 1774?
Townspeople attempted to relocate it, but it broke in half during the move.
What happened to Plymouth Rock in the 19th century?
It was displayed at Pilgrim Hall Museum before being reunited with its other half in 1880.
When was the date “1620” inscribed on Plymouth Rock?
In 1880, when the two halves were rejoined.
How much of the original Plymouth Rock remains today?
Only about one-third of its original estimated 20,000-pound size.
Did the Pilgrims land at Plymouth first?
No, they initially landed at Provincetown on Cape Cod before settling in Plymouth.
Has Plymouth Rock been used for souvenirs?
Yes, pieces of the rock were chipped off and distributed, including to museums.
Who designed the current canopy over Plymouth Rock?
The architectural firm McKim, Mead & White designed the Roman Doric portico in 1920.
What were the early European settlements that failed in North America?
