The schism between Western Christianity, represented by the Roman Catholic Church, and Eastern Christianity, represented by the Eastern Orthodox Church, is rooted in deep theological, political, and cultural differences that have existed for centuries. These tensions have occasionally erupted into open conflict, shaping the course of history in profound ways.

Below, WHE exploreS significant moments when these two branches of Christianity clashed, either directly or as part of broader political and military conflicts.

1.    The Photian Schism (863-867 and 877-886)

The Photian Schism was one of the earliest significant conflicts between the Western and Eastern Churches, centering on the legitimacy of Patriarch Photius of Constantinople.

The schism began when Ignatius, the deposed patriarch, sought the support of Pope Nicholas I, who declared Photius’s elevation to the patriarchate invalid. This ecclesiastical dispute quickly escalated into broader issues, including the insertion of the Filioque clause into the Nicene Creed by the Western Church, a doctrinal change not accepted by the East. Though the schism was eventually resolved, it laid the groundwork for centuries of mistrust and disagreement.

Image: Photius

10 Most Influential Catholic Popes from the Middle Ages

2.    The East-West Schism (1054)

The formal split between the Eastern Orthodox and Roman Catholic Churches occurred in 1054, a culmination of long-standing disputes over theological doctrines, ecclesiastical jurisdiction, and political authority. Central to the conflict were issues like the Filioque clause and the authority of the Pope. The mutual excommunications by Pope Leo IX and Patriarch Michael Cerularius formalized the division, fundamentally altering the Christian world and setting the stage for future conflicts.

Image: Miniature of Pope Leo IX

3.    The Fourth Crusade (1202-1204)

One of the most dramatic clashes between Western and Eastern Christianity occurred during the Fourth Crusade. Originally intended to recapture Jerusalem from Muslim control, the Crusade was diverted to Constantinople, largely due to the influence of Venetian merchants and the need for financial and military support.

In 1204, Crusaders sacked Constantinople, leading to the establishment of the Latin Empire and significantly weakening the Byzantine Empire. This event deepened the schism and engendered a lasting bitterness towards the West within the Eastern Christian world.

READ MORE: How and why did the Roman Catholics sack Constantinople in 1204?

4.    The Massacre of the Latins (1182)

Before the Fourth Crusade, there was significant tension in Constantinople regarding the presence of Western merchants and settlers, known as “Latins.” In 1182, these tensions exploded into violence when a large-scale massacre of Western residents occurred. This massacre was a clear demonstration of the hostility between the two branches of Christianity, driven by both economic competition and religious differences.

5.    The Sack of Thessalonica (904)

While not a direct conflict between the churches, the sack of Thessalonica by Muslim forces in 904 was influenced by the religious and political dynamics between East and West. The inability of the Byzantine Empire to secure Western military support against the raid highlighted the growing estrangement between the two Christian realms, which some historians see as a contributing factor to the city’s vulnerability.

6.    The Crusader States and the Byzantine Empire

The establishment of the Crusader States in the Holy Land following the First Crusade (1096-1099) created a new arena of interaction between Eastern and Western Christianity. While initially cooperative, the relationship between the Crusaders and the Byzantine Empire became increasingly strained over territorial and military issues. These tensions occasionally led to conflicts, as both sides maneuvered for control and influence in the region.

7.    The Battle of Manzikert (1071)

Although primarily a confrontation between the Byzantine Empire and the Seljuk Turks, the Battle of Manzikert had significant implications for East-West Christian relations. The Byzantine defeat weakened the empire, making it more susceptible to later Crusader influence and intervention. The event indirectly influenced the schismatic relationships by highlighting the Byzantine Empire’s vulnerability and the West’s growing militaristic ambitions in Eastern territories.

Image: The Battle of Manzikert, as portrayed on a 15th-century artwork.

8.    The Councils of Lyons (1245 and 1274)

The Second Council of Lyons in 1274 attempted to reunite the Eastern and Western Churches. The council decreed a union that was largely political, driven by the West’s desire to assert control over Eastern Christianity and to enlist support against the Muslim threat. The union was met with significant resistance in Byzantium, where it was seen as a betrayal of Orthodox traditions.

9.    The Fall of Constantinople (1453) and its Aftermath

The fall of Constantinople to the Ottoman Turks was a catastrophic event for Eastern Christianity but was met with mixed reactions in the West. Some in the Western Church saw the fall of the Byzantine Empire as a divine punishment for the Eastern Church’s refusal to submit to papal authority. The event failed to spur a united Christian response, highlighting the deep division between East and West.

Read More: Top 10 Ottoman Sultans and their Accomplishments